REVIEW QUESTIONS ON GEMARA AND RASHI
prepared by Rabbi Eliezer Chrysler
Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Jerusalem
Previous dafTa'anis 18
TA'ANIS 17, 18, 19 - Ari Kornfeld has generously sponsored the Dafyomi
publications for these Dafim for the benefit of Klal Yisrael
(a) We just concluded that Chazal included Pesach in the Yom-Tov
de'Rabbanan, in order to prohibit fasting even on the day *after* Pesach.
Who would then have to be the author of the Beraisa?
(b) What problem does that present us with regard to the Reisha, where we
explained that they included Rosh Chodesh Nisan in the Yamim-Tovim
de'Rabbanan in order to forbid fasting on the day before (the twenty-ninth
(c) Which three decrees were nullified on the twenty-eighth of Nisan?
(d) Acting on the advice of a Roman matron, how did Yehudah ben Shamu'a and
his colleagues proceed to have them nullified?
(a) Abaye explains that it was nevertheless necessary to include Rosh
Chodesh Nisan in the Yamim-Tovim de'Rabbanan, because of a leap-year.
does he mean (according to Rashi's first explanation)?
(b) Rav Ashi maintains that it was necessary anyway, even not in a leap-
Why is that? What does Rebbi Yossi *normally* mean when he says
(a) Why did Chazal find it necessary to include the eighth of Nisan in the
second group of days (from the eighth until after Pesach), seeing as it was
already included in the first group (from the first until the eighth)?
(b) Why did we need to include the *eighth* in the second group to achieve
that? Why could we not institute the Yom-Tov from the ninth, and then rely
on the fact that the eighth is anyway the day before the ninth, and
therefore forbidden to fast?
(c) How do we use this answer to answer the Kashya that we asked earlier (in
1b.) with regard to Rosh Chodesh Nisan and the twenty ninth of Adar?
(a) Rav rules like Rebbi Yossi (who forbids fasting both the day before and
the day after the Yamim-Tovim mentioned in Megilas Ta'anis).
Answers to questions
(b) What does Raban Shimon ben Gamliel in a Beraisa learn from the fact that
Chazal use the expression 'Behon' twice (' ... de'Lo le'His'ana Behon ...
u'de'Lo le'Misped Behon')?
(c) How do we now reconcile Shmuel, who ruled like Rebbi Meir, but who
appears to contradict himself by ruling like Raban Shimon ben Gamliel?
(d) Ba'ali quoting Rebbi Chiya bar Aba Amar Rebbi Yochanan rules like Rebbi
Yossi (like Rav).
How does Rebbi Chiya bar Aba restrict Rebbi Yochanan's
(a) The Mishnah in Megilah says that those people who read the Megilah
early, are nevertheless permitted to eulogize and to fast on that day. Why
can this not be referring to ...
1. ... someone from a walled city (who normally reads the Megilah on the
fifteenth of Adar), who spends the day in an open town (and who therefore
reads it on the fourteenth)?
(b) Assuming therefore, that the Tana must be referring to someone from an
open town who spends the day in a village on the eleventh of Adar (and who
therefore reads the Megilah then), why does this present us with a Kashya on
Rebbi Yochanan (who, we just saw, rules like Rebbi Yossi)? How do we know
that that Mishnah (whose author is Rebbi Meir) is Halachah anyway?
2. ... someone from an open town who is in a village on the thirteenth (and
who therefore reads it then)?
3. ... someone from an open town who is in a village on the twelfth?
(a) So we establish the Mishnah by people from an open town who spent the
day in a village on the twelth.
Why is there no problem with the fact that
it is ...
(b) Yom Terainus was absolved because Sh'mayah and Achyo were killed on that
day. Who were Sh'mayah and Achyo? Were they the ones who were eaten by a
- ... Yom Terainus?
- ... the day before Yom Nikanor?
(c) What is the significance of Yom Nikanor? What happened to Nikanor in the
(a) What did Terainus tell the two brothers Lulinus and Papus prior to
(b) What did they answer him?
(c) He killed them anyway.
What happened to him (which resulted in Chazal
fixing that day as a Yom-Tov)?
(d) Lulinus and Papus are referred elsewhere as 'Harugei Lud'.
they possibly have done for the Gemara to write about them that no-one can
stand in their place?
(a) We learned in our Mishnah that, once they have begun fasting, they
continue fasting even on Rosh Chodesh, Chanukah and Purim. According to
Rav Acha, by 'begun', the Tana means three times.
***** Hadran Alach, Seder Ta'aniyos Keitzad *****
What does Rebbi Yossi
(an Amora) say?
(b) We also learned in our Mishnah that, in the opinion of Rebbi Meir,
although Raban Gamliel holds that, once one has begun to fast, he continues
fasting even on the three Yamim-Tovim, nevertheless hes does not complete
Is this opinion unanimous?
(c) What is the Halachah?
***** Perek Seder Ta'aniyos Eilu *****
(a) Does the Seider of fasts that we learned until now (first the Yechidim,
and then the Tzibur, who first fast three fasts, then three and then seven
etc.) apply even if the plants failed to grow as they were planted (e.g. if
thorns grew instead of wheat)?
Answers to questions
(b) The same applies if the rain began falling and then stopped (which is
called a drought) for a significant period before the next fall (since it
signififies a drought).
What is the length of that significant period?
(c) When does one begin fasting if rain did fall ...
(d) If sufficient water fell for the needs of one town but not for its
neighbor, what must the inhabitants of the ...
- ... but only sufficient for the plants but not for the trees or in a way that the trees were watered but not the plants?
- ... if sufficient rain fell to water the plants and the trees, but not to fill the pits?
- ... town for which sufficient rain fell, do? Why is that?
- ... surrounding districts do (according to the Tana Kama)?