POINT BY POINT SUMMARY
by Rabbi Ephraim Becker
Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Yerushalayim
Rosh Kollel: Rabbi Mordecai Kornfeld
Ask A Question on the daf
Previous dafSukah 51
SUKA 36-56 (End of Maseches) have been dedicated by the wife and daughters
of the late Dr. Simcha Bekelnitzky (Simcha Gedalya ben Shraga Feibush) of
Queens N.Y. Well known in the community for his Chesed and Tzedakah, he will
long be remembered.
1) SHIRAH AS PRIMARILY WITH THE MOUTH OR WITH INSTRUMENTS
(a) (R. Papa) This is a Machlokes Tanaim as follows:
2) THE MACHLOKES R. YOSI B. YEHUDAH AND RABANAN (resumed)
1. (R. Meir) The Avadim of the Kohanim played.
(b) Question: Then what is R. Yosi's position?!
2. (R. Yosi) Yisraelim of specific families played.
3. (R. Chanina b. Antignus) Levi'im played.
4. Seemingly, R. Meir (who allows Avadim to play)
must hold that Shirah is with the mouth, while R.
Chanina must hold that Shirah is primarily with a
Keli (thus Levi'im would need to play).
1. If Shirah is b'Feh, Avadim should be permitted!
(c) Answer: Shirah is with the mouth and the Machlokes is
over what actually happened (who played).
2. If Shirah is b'Keli, Levi'im should be required!
(d) Question: What Halachic difference does it make?
(e) Answer: It will affect the assumptions we make about
people on the Duchan regarding Ma'aser and Yuchsin.
1. If Avadim were on the Duchan, then no assumptions
can be made regarding either Yuchsin or Ma'aser.
2. If Yisraelim, then infer Yuchsin but not Ma'aser.
3. If Levi'im, then infer both.
(a) (R. Yirmiyah b. Aba) They argued only whether the
Chalil was Docheh Shabbos for Simchas Beis HaShoevah
(R. Yosi b. Yehudah) or not (Rabanan).
3) MISHNAH: THE GREAT SIMCHAS BEIS HASHOEVAH
(b) All would permit the Chalil for the Shir of the Korban,
which is actually Avodah.
(c) Question (on R. Yosef who, on 50b, taught that R. Yosi
concurs with Chachamim that Shir of Simchas Beis
HaShoevah is not Docheh Shabbos [while the Shir of
Korban is a Machlokes]): The Beraisa teaches that,
according to R. Yosi b. Yehudah, the Shir of Simchas
Beis HaShoevah *is* Docheh Shabbos!?
(d) Answer: This refutes R. Yosef.
(e) Question: We may infer from this Beraisa that the
Machlokes is *only* regarding Shir of Beis HaShoevah,
and that all agree to permit Shir of Korban (refuting
the premise R. Yosef that this is a Machlokes)!?
(f) Answer: They argue regarding both Shir, but they single
out Beis HaShoevah to teach the extent of R. Yosi's
permission (even Beis HaShoevah is Docheh Shabbos).
(g) Question: But our Mishnah teaches that Chalil of *Beis
HaShoevah* is not Docheh Shabbos (implying that the
Shir of Korban *is* Docheh Shabbos)!?
1. The author of this statement cannot be R. Yosi b.
Yehudah (who holds that Beis HaShoevah is Docheh.
(h) Answer: R. Yosef is thus refuted on two counts.
2. It must be Rabanan, thus refuting R. Yosef!
(i) The basis for Shira being primarily b'Keli is the Pasuk
Vayomer Chizkiyahu... (Divrei HaYamim II:29).
(j) The basis for Shira b'Feh is Vayehi k'Echad (ibid:5).
1. Question: Then what of the Pasuk Vayomer...?
2. Answer: It is understood as Shirah starting b'Feh.
3. Question: How will Vayehi be understood by those
who hold Shirah b'Keli?
4. Answer: The singers in the Pasuk are compared to
the trumpeters in that they used Keilim.
(a) It was an incomparable Simchah.
(b) After the first YomTov the Kohanim and Levi'im would
descend to the Ezras Nashim to make the Tikun Gadol.
(c) There were golden Menoros with four ladders reaching
the four receptacles on top of each Menorah.
(d) Young Kohanim would bring 120 Lugim of oil into each
Sefel, and worn Bigdei Kehunah would be cut for wicks.
(e) The light illuminated every courtyard in Yerushalayim
(f) Great men danced and juggled torches and sang praises.
4) INCOMPARABLE EVENTS
(g) Levi'im played all manner of instruments while standing
on the 15 steps down to the Ezras Nashim (representing
the 15 Shir HaMa'alos in Tehilim).
(h) Two Kohanim trumpeters blew from above the steps at
daybreak, descended to the tenth step and blew again,
continuing until the eastern gate of the Ezras Nashim.
(i) They turned westward (back upon the Mikdash) and
proclaimed that our ancestors angered HaShem while our
eyes turn only to HaShem.
(j) According to R. Yehudah, they repeated Anu l'Kah...
(a) The Simchas Beis HaShoevah was a singular Simchah.
5) THE TIKUN GADOL
(b) Yerushalayim was a uniquely beautiful city.
(c) The Beis HaMikdash was uniquely magnificent.
1. Question: Which Mikdash?
(d) (R. Yehudah in the Beraisa) The Beis HaKeneses in
Alexandria was a unique glory for the Jews at times
holding 600,000 (some say twice that number of) Jews.
2. Answer: The Mikdash built by Hordus.
3. Question: What was its construction?
4. Answer (Rabah): Green and white marble
(alternately, blue and white marble).
5. Each successive row of stones was slightly
recessed from the row below it, to properly retain
6. The Rabanan discouraged Hordus from gold plating
1. The building is described in detail, including the
wooden Bimah in the middle where the Shamash would
wave cloths to tell the masses to answer Amen.
(e) (Abaye) They were all killed by Alexander Mokdon.
2. People sat by vocation, and a poor newcomer would
join his guild there and be supported.
(f) Question: Why were they punished?
(g) Answer: Because they violated the prohibition of
returning to Mitzrayim.
(h) Alexander came there and inferred from the Torah
reading, which foretold his miraculous arrival, that he
was to carry out the punishment spoken of in that
Parashah, and he did so.
(a) Question: What great thing was instituted?
(b) Answer: They created a balcony for the women above,
since the previous arrangements had led to levity.
(c) Question: But how could they add to the Mikdash, which
must follow the plans laid out by the Pasuk!?
(d) Answer (Rav): They learned a Kal VaChomer from the
separation mandated at the eulogy of Mashiach ben Yosef
to the separation at the joyous occasions.